Jogging Stroller Smackdown

| July 16, 2013 | 9 Comments

By Zoe Wedel

I thought I had found the holy grail of strollers with the BOB Revolution SE. However, I have to admit that my “faith” was tested when Women’s Adventure gave me the Bumbleride Indie to review. In the past month, I’ve really gotten to know the Indie, and I like it. So now I’m not sure what to do. Which should I keep? Here’s a side by side comparison of the two strollers so you can make the hard decision for yourself.

stroller for facebook

Let’s face it. These two urban, all-terrain vehicles are similar in more ways than one. Aside from the basic form (three wheels, not four), the way the two strollers open and collapse is almost identical. Both have a locking front wheel and tires that have to be regularly inflated using a bicycle pump. Both have large canopies to cover your precious cargo from the sun.

The Indie feels like a luxury cross-over SUV, while the Revolution SE is more like a rugged Jeep Wrangler. In my opinion, the Indie triumphs over the Revolution SE in a number of areas: weight, footprint, infant comfort, storage, and very important–curb appeal. The Indie weighs in at 20 pounds, five pounds lighter than the Revolution, which makes it easier for me to get it in and out of the car. It also feels more compact, in part due to smaller dimensions, but also because of the shape of the canopy. The Indie’s canopy is rounded whereas the Revolution’s is boxy.

With a super padded seat that can be adjusted to support his legs and feet, my 6-month old is more comfy in the Indie (as long as we’re just pounding pavement). When he’s in the Revolution, his short legs tend to stick straight out over the edge of the seat. Another bonus is that my little one stays asleep longer in the Indie after we’re finished with our walk.

Important for grocery and beer runs is storage. The Indie also does better in this category. The storage capacity of the two strollers may be similar, but good luck getting anything as big as a carton of juice in the Revolution. The Indie’s storage is much easier to access and therefore more shopping-friendly. And last but not least, the Indie just looks better. It’s got nicer lines and a better selection of bright, appealing colors. One passerby actually told me that she thought my Green Papyrus Indie looked “happy.” The dark, muted Revolution SE colors, on the other hand, are a snooze fest.

So what about the BOB? With its big back wheels and awesome shocks, the Revolution SE is, hands-down, better for more serious running and for trails.

Long story short, if you are a casual road runner, running a 10+ min mile, a couple times a week, the Bumbleride Indie is a sleek alternative to the Bob Revolution SE. As for which I plan to keep–we’ll see. If only I had the space for both!

Zoe lives in Boulder, CO and is a full-time baby mama, part-time business analyst and would be triathlete. Her passions include the Russian language, swimming, and local grassroots conservation (check out where Zoe used to work to learn about a really innovative environmental non-profit).  

Category: Gear

About the Author ()

Written by the dedicated, hard-working Women's Adventure staff and their very generous team of volunteer writers. Want to lend a hand at making this splendid magazine even more splendid? Contact us at and let us know!

Comments (9)

Trackback URL | Comments RSS Feed

  1. Lia Keller says:

    Interesting comparison! I like my ‘Jeep Wrangler’ (aka Bob) as I am tough and go off road quite often, but I love the cushy-ness of that Bumbleride!

  2. PeppyParents says:

    Nice comparison, great insights into how the Indie distinguishes itself apart!

  3. Zoe Wedel says:

    So I still have both strollers and I still LOVE my Indie. It definitely has some awesome qualities. I’ve been wondering what kind of stroller Prince George will ride in. My vote’s for the Indie – way more regal.

  4. Susan Brian says:

    I think that BOB is more for power jogging while Indie is more for power walking. Indie is definitely more comfi for the child and has a lot of luxury features that BOB doesn’t. Susan

  5. Lauren Smith says:

    My personal opinion is that BOB is really great while you jog. It gives your child better comfort while you are on the move. Indie on the other side is meant for people who take their children out occasionally for walks or inside a shopping mall.

  6. Zosimos Ubol says:

    I can’t say how much I love Bumbleride Indie Stroller! It’s light and fairly compact when folded and easily fits in my small car.

  7. Alison says:

    Comparing them to vehicles is quite funny but I have to agree, it’s a great correspondence. In this case, the Indie is totally a win-win. But in your case, I would definitely keep both. Haha! Great review anyway! 🙂

  8. Jen says:

    Thank you! Great article. I am researching jogging strollers and these two are on my shortlist! I had drawn a sinilar conclusion!

  9. Jonna says:

    So what did you decide? Are you selling one? I might buy!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *